Your Premier Destination for Custom Knives in New York City

Custom Knife Purveyor

At KnifeLegends, we pride ourselves on being the ultimate destination for discerning knife enthusiasts in New York City. Founded by Paul Shindler, his journey began with a childhood fascination for pocket and jack knives, evolving into a lifelong passion for the artistry and craftsmanship of custom blades.

Paul’s immersion into the world of knives took root in the summer of 1976, during his tenure at America’s oldest cutlery store, where he spent months selling high-end fly fishing tackle. Amidst assisting customers and managing stock, Paul found himself drawn to the hunting knives department, where he encountered his first-hand made treasures by esteemed artisans such as Randall and Ralph Bone.

Bob Loveless KnifeWarren Osborne knife custom knife dealersTore Fogarizzu Custom Knife

The pivotal moment came in 1988 when Paul was introduced to his first high-end, sole-authorship blades by renowned craftsmen including Joe Kious, Kaj Embretsen, Michael Walker, Larry Fuegen, Bill Pease, and Frank Centofante. From that moment on, he was captivated, embarking on a twelve-year journey traveling to knife shows across the country to meet his favorite makers.

Joe Kious Custom KnivesKaj Embretsen Custom KnivesMichael Walker custom knife

At KnifeLegends, we specialize in curating top-of-the-line, investment-grade folders and fixed blades, as well as knives with intricate engraving, catering to collectors with discerning tastes and an appreciation for exceptional craftsmanship.

As a full-time Knife Purveyor, Paul relishes the opportunity to engage with fellow enthusiasts, sharing stories, and experiencing the artistry of these exquisite blades firsthand. Every knife at KnifeLegends tells a story, and we invite you to explore our collection and find your own treasure.

Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a novice enthusiast, KnifeLegends is your trusted partner in acquiring the finest custom knives in New York City. Experience the artistry, craftsmanship, and passion that define KnifeLegends today.