Buying a custom knife is not just about getting a tool for a particular task—it’s about investing in craftsmanship, quality, and design. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a first-time buyer, knowing what to look for when purchasing custom knives is crucial to ensuring you get a high-quality piece that suits your needs and personal style. From the materials used to the maker’s reputation, here are the key factors to consider before making a purchase.
1. Blade Material and Quality
The blade material is one of the most important factors when buying a custom knife. High-quality steel is essential for a durable and sharp blade. Common materials used for custom knife blades include:
- Stainless Steel: Known for its corrosion resistance, stainless steel is a popular choice. High-end stainless-steel types like ATS-34, RWL-34, BG-42, CPM-S30V, VG-10, and Damascus steel offer superior edge retention and strength.
- Carbon Steel: Carbon steel is known for being easy to sharpen and holding an edge well. However, it requires more maintenance to prevent rusting.
- Damascus Steel: This is a layered steel known for its beautiful patterns, often used in high-end knives. Damascus is both functional and aesthetically pleasing, combining strength and sharpness with a unique design.
Look for steel with a balance of hardness and toughness. Harder steel retains an edge for longer but can be more brittle, while tougher steel can handle impacts without chipping but may require more frequent sharpening.
2. Blade Shape and Functionality
The shape of the blade determines its intended function. Custom knives come in a variety of blade shapes, each designed for a specific purpose. Here are a few common types:
- Drop Point Blade: This versatile blade shape features a slight curve toward the tip and is ideal for general-purpose tasks like hunting or everyday carry (EDC).
- Clip Point Blade: Known for its pointed tip, the clip point blade is excellent for precision tasks such as slicing and piercing.
- Tanto Blade: The tanto blade features a sharp, angular point and is ideal for heavy-duty tasks, such as prying or piercing tough materials.
- Straight Blade – the tang is straight from the guard to the tip without any curve or drop.
- Dagger Blade – a symmetrical blade that has the same profile and edge on both sides
- Wharncliffe Blade: This blade shape is great for detail work and carving, with a straight edge and a pronounced curve toward the tip.
There are many other blade shapes including: Spey, Sheepsfoot, Gut Hook, Pro Hunter, Fighter, Sub Hilt Fighter and so on. Many of these shapes are specialized Fighting or Hunting Shapes which are not commonly seen on collector knives.
Choosing the right blade shape depends on your intended use. Whether you’re looking for a practical tool or a showpiece for your collection, the blade shape should reflect your needs.
3. Handle Material and Design
The handle of a custom knife is just as important as the blade. Not only does the handle affect the knife’s comfort and ergonomics, but it also plays a big role in the overall aesthetic. High-quality custom knife handles are typically made from materials like:
- Wood: Exotic woods like Ebony, Snakewood, Desert Ironwood, Cocobolo, Walnut, Maple, or Rosewood provide a beautiful, natural look. Wood handles often offer a unique grip that ages well over time.
- G10: This composite material is known for its strength and resistance to weather conditions. It is commonly used in tactical and outdoor knives.
- Micarta: Made from layers of linen or paper and resin, Micarta is lightweight and durable, offering a solid grip. Micarta is not affected by temperature, humidity or nuclear explosion, it will basically last forever. The favorite handle material of Bob Loveless.
- Bone and Horn: These materials are often used in traditional custom knives for their vintage appeal.
- Gem Quality Stones: Often used in high-end Art knives, Gem Quality Stone can offer the ultimate in lasting beauty.
The handle should feel comfortable in your hand, with an ergonomic design that allows for a secure grip during use. Bob Loveless used to say that is a knife handle is really comfortable you should not want to put the knife down!
4. Fit and Finish
The fit and finish of a custom knife reflect the level of craftsmanship involved in its creation. High-end custom knives should have:
- Tight tolerances: No loose parts, especially around the blade, lock, and pivot.
- Smooth, even surfaces: There should be no rough edges or visible marks on the blade or handle.
- Well-aligned components: The blade should open and close smoothly, and the lock should engage firmly.
- Walk and Talk – every folding knife has a unique feel and sound when you are opening, closing and locking the blade. This is called the Walk and Talk. Knives by many famous makers have a unique walk and talk that can easily be identified by experience collectors.
A knife with impeccable fit and finish not only performs well but also shows the skill and dedication of the maker.
5. Maker’s Reputation
One of the most important factors when buying a custom knife is the reputation of the maker. Established custom knife makers often have a long track record of producing high-quality knives and can provide provenance for their work. Research the maker’s background, reviews, and any awards or recognition they have received to ensure you are purchasing from a reputable source. There are also a few knife makers who prefer not to service their knives, so you might want to find out about this before making your purchase. If the maker is no longer living it’s is a good idea to ask your dealer if there is another high-grade maker who is willing to deal with small scratches or handling marks that could occur over the years you own the knife.
6. Price vs. Value
Custom knives can range from a few hundred to many thousands of dollars. While price can be an indicator of quality, it’s essential to evaluate the value you’re getting for your investment. A well-crafted knife made by a skilled artisan, using high-quality materials, is worth the cost.
However, make sure the price aligns with the knife makers reputation as well as the knife’s materials, craftsmanship, and functionality. If a maker with little experience is asking a lot for his work that could be a read flag worth discussing with a trusted dealer. For example, a new unrated smith, who is asking as much for his work as that of a highly rated master smith, resale value could be a problem.
When to Contact KnifeLegends
If you’re looking for a custom knife that blends artistry with functionality, KnifeLegends is your go-to destination. With an extensive selection of rare and high-quality custom knives from renowned makers, KnifeLegends ensures that every knife in their collection meets the highest standards of craftsmanship. Whether you’re an avid collector or just starting out, KnifeLegends offers expert guidance and access to knives that will enhance any collection. Contact KnifeLegends today for personalized advice and to find the perfect custom knife for your needs.